Dog Crate Review: Find the Perfect Fit for Your Dog

Lead and Collar Jan 17, 2024
11 People Read

Hello and welcome back to the Lead & Collar Blog, where our goal is to provide high value education and resources for beginner dog owners.

This week we are chatting about crates. There are lots options out there, but I’ve chosen a few specific options that will suit a range of different dog owners.

To simplify things a bit, I've categorised them into three sections:

  • Soft Crates

  • Hard Crates

  • Furniture Crates

But the million-dollar question remains – which one is right for you?

Now, I’m not going to tell you which one to buy, but I can certainly share my thoughts on the matter.

So let’s go!


Soft Crates

These crates are amazing for a light weight travel alternative.

People also use these crates at agility or obedience competitions as a place for their dog to rest up during events as well as at home. I recommend using in conjunction with a hard crate for transport as they provide no protection from crashes or impacts.

My sister, with her duo of a miniature dachshund and a king charles cavalier spaniel, swears by soft crates. And why not? They're perfect for small dogs.

But…and it's a big but, if your dog has anxiety or has high drive to get out of the crate, they might not be for you – those soft walls can be chewed through, leading to a newfound freedom!

In summary, they’re great because:

  • Ideal for crate loving dogs

  • Suited for travelling

  • Light weight

Option 1: Elite Field 3-door Sage Green Soft Dog Crate

It’s a standout in the realm of soft crates and a crowd favourite for good reason. Having undergone our own rigorous testing, it's clear why this crate has secured its popularity.

With a sturdy design crafted from quality materials, the process of setting up and taking down the crate is a seamless affair. Featuring three doors and mesh windows, the crate ensures optimal ventilation, and the attached carrying bag simplifies the task of keeping your pup's belongings organised while on the move.

While the fleece bed might be on the thinner side, it still adds a touch of comfort that doesn't go unnoticed.

Pros:

  • Light weight

  • Collapsible

  • Easy assembly steel tube frame

  • Carrying bag

  • Free crate matt

  • Top, front, and side doors for convenience

  • Two accessory pockets on the top and side

  • Well ventilated

  • Removable and washable cover and mat

Cons:

  • No crash protection

  • Not suitable for anxious or high drive dogs who aren’t fans of crates

  • No insulation from external environmental temperatures

  • More easily escapable


Hard Crates

Now, here's where I spill the tea: hard crates are the go to for me. Tried, tested, and true with our furry companions, they're the Jack-of-all-trades. Whether we're camping, visiting the folks' farm, or just on a spontaneous ute trip, these crates are the real MVPs.

  • Perfect from puppies to the largest dog

  • Ideal for all training levels

  • Great for travel

  • Semi or permanently set up areas

Option 1: GUNNER G1 Kennel 

Behold the pinnacle – the Rolls-Royce of dog crates.

Crafted from double-wall rotomolded plastic, this crate is a testament to top-tier construction. Boasting 4 tie-down points and 2 carry handles for easy manoeuvring, the large variant even throws in two rollers at the back for a smooth glide.

For the folks always on the move, seeking a safe and secure transport haven for their furry companions, this crate takes the lead.

But wait, there's more – a suite of accessories, including a water bowl and fan kit, to keep your four-legged friend cool and refreshed. Add in the lifetime manufacturer warranty, and you've got yourself a stellar choice.

Now, a couple of pointers for the savvy consumer – thanks to its structural design, the internals feature thick walls, making it larger overall compared to its counterparts. Something to consider when pondering your specific use cases (ie: how much space you have) – all the specs are laid out on the website.

Also keep in mind this crate arrives flat-packed, so you’ll need to assemble it.

Poodle in Gunner crate

Pros:

  • 5 star crash tested

  • Provides some insulation from outside temperatures due to its construction design

  • Large range of extras

  • Sturdy tie down points

  • Lifetime manufacture warranty

  • Lockable (2x additional locking tabs on door for extra security)

Cons:

  • Expensive

  • Takes up more space than similar internal size crate

  • Significantly heavier than similar size crate

  • Not collapsible for transport or storage

retriever next to gunner crate

Option 2: IMPACT Collapsible Dog Crate

impact crates white

Here's a crate that's earned a nod of approval from the dog training community.

Crafted from robust aluminium, this lightweight crate doesn't compromise on sturdiness. Collapsible at the drop of a hat, it boasts two convenient carry handles and the structural prowess to be neatly stacked, one atop the other.

Tailor-made for the globetrotters and those seeking a sturdy, packable companion for their adventures or when going to competitions, this crate is the answer.

And here's a bonus…

There are specialised models catering to specific needs, such as the high anxiety crate designed to help with your dog's anxiety levels by minimising your dogs inputs from outside the crate. Like the Gunner, this also comes with accessories like a fan and water bowl.

A minor note of caution: due to its construction, this crate might generate a bit of noise as your dog manoeuvres within it. However, when in transit, it doesn’t rattle, and it’s clear the design prioritises integrity.

Boxer in IMPACT crate

Pros:

  • Set up In 60 seconds

  • Easy carrying handle

  • Ventilated for optimal airflow

  • One-handed operation

  • Light weight

  • Collapsible for transport

  • Lifetime guarantee

  • 10yr dog damage warranty (only on high anxiety crate)

Cons:

  • Expensive

  • Due to its construction is loud when dog moves around inside

  • Provides no insulation from outside temperatures

  • Not crash tested

impact crate

Option 3: Snooza – Dog – 2 in 1 – Convertible Graphite Training Crate

snooza 2 in 1 crate

Meet the ever-reliable Old Faithful.

This is the go-to crate that marks the starting line for many.

Fashioned from wire, this crate is simple – easily collapsible, lightweight, and featuring a removable tray for easy cleaning, making it a training haven for those lively puppies.

Ideal for those embarking on their crate journey, it's a budget-friendly option that opens the door to the world of dog ownership. A perfect fit for your home sanctuary, where you can unwind and dedicate time to shaping your pup into the perfect companion.

What makes it stand out? Well, you can take off the doors if you fancy turning it into a cozy den for your pup to chill.

Now, a word of caution for those with high-anxiety or high-drive four-legged raptors in the family – this might not be the crate for you.

While it stands strong, the construction and materials can make it unsuitable, with potential escape route for the determined ones, and the latches aren't built to withstand a beating. This isn't a dig at the design; it's just a heads-up on the ideal use case for this particular style of crate.

collie in snooza crate

Pros:

  • Low cost

  • Light weight

  • Collapsible

  • Great ventilation

  • Removable tray for cleaning

  • Removable doors for a kennel transformation

Cons:

  • High drive or anxious dogs can easily escape

  • Provides no protection in car accident

  • No insulation from outside temperatures


Furniture Crate

Now, let's talk luxury – furniture crates. They're a statement piece and a permanent fixture all in one. But, fair warning, they're not cheap. Yet, the aesthetic payoff is downright incredible.

  • Made to suit all sizes

  • Permanent setups that feel like they were meant to be there

  • Can be designed to have drawers for all your pup’s needs

  • Customisable

Option 1: Kustom Kennels

Kustom kennel

For aficionados of all things custom, your search ends here.

Behold, handmade furniture crates meticulously crafted to seamlessly blend into your home, becoming an integral part of the household aesthetic. Whether catering to multiple canine companions or a solitary pooch, these crates, constructed with a blend of wood and steel, not only serve their purpose but also add a touch of elegance.

Crafted for the dog owner with a distinct vision, these crates are the epitome of merging dog ownership seamlessly with living spaces. If you don't mind splurging a bit for your pup or if you simply revel in providing your furry friend with a posh retreat, look no further – this is the crate tailored to your taste.

But, a word to the wise– while these custom crates are fantastic, exercise caution if your pup hasn't fully embraced the idea of crate comfort just yet. It might be wise to hold off until they're joyfully accustomed to chilling in a crate. After all, repairs for these personalised gems can venture into the pricey realm, particularly if you're dealing with a chewer. Keep in mind that the warranty only covers shipping and any build defects for a limited time, emphasising the need for a well-settled canine occupant before investing in this upscale retreat.

Kustom Kennel

Pros:

  • Custom design available

  • Looks great

  • Can be made to have storage

  • Multiple crates in one

Cons:

  • Expensive

  • Costly to repair

  • Limited warranty

  • Not great for training


Conclusion

Well, thats my 2 cents on dog crates.

Whether you lean towards practicality with soft or hard crates or embrace luxury with furniture crates, or both, your choice reflects your lifestyle and requirements for your pup.

I hope you found this information valuable - I certainly did researching and talking to dog owners and the training community.

As always, if you have any questions about the ins and outs of owning a dog, feel free to reach out to us via our contact page. We can’t wait to hear from you - Happy training!